The experience I had Wenningers Auto was great. Adam the Sales Manager was very helpful and got me into the right vehicle with the right budget I had. My 2003 Dodge Ram 1500 I purchased runs and drives like a dream and couldn't have expected anything more. With minor body rust issues everything shows its age and couldnt have expected anything more or less. When it's used you get what you pay for, Guaranteed and would definitely go back if another vehicle was needed.

I happened to stumble upon this place while driving out to a work office location in Beaver Dam, otherwise I would have never known they exist. My current car happened to be falling apart and I was in desperate need of something reliable and affordable. I checked out their online inventory and found a 2011 Honda CR-V with only 101,000 miles, which was one of my top car choices for reliability and longevity. I scheduled a test drive and showed up right before close, but the guys there were really nice about it because they knew I was coming from work. I decided to move forward with purchasing the vehicle and the process was quite simple and there was no pressuring from anyone on the sales team. They even came down $800 on the car price so I could workout a smaller down payment with Marine Credit Union, whom they do financing through. Thanks to their flexibility, I was able to purchase the car I wanted, and I have been happy with it since purchasing 3 weeks ago. I love my car and for that being the first car buying experience I have had in over a decade, it was a lot easier than I expected, and everyone at Wenninger's was super nice. Thanks guys!

Sold a vehicle that was "inspected" but the breaks were scraping within a week after delivery. This is the smallest issue with the vehicle. BUYERS BEWARE!!!!!!!!!

This place is the definition of shady! They couldn't make it as a carpet store, so they decided they would try used cars. Their mato is "I never saw a leak that stop leak can't fix" NEVER trust a salesman especially one that sells used cars.

Advertised one price...drove over an hour to find...the price didn't include freight, prep and windshield. Exact definition of bait and switch. Watch yourself at this place honestly is not a priority there. They even admitted the advertisement was incorrect but would stand behind it.

For being a “family owned” establishment and the reviews online I expected more. Traded in a SUV and was told that they could only give me a small amount due to all the mechanical issues and mileage. Which honestly I didn’t expect much going into this. But to my surprise I see my traded in SUV on the website this week listed as a mechanic special for $2,499! That’s over a $2,100 profit when I was told the amount I originally wanted was too high. And it wasn’t even that much! That’s shady as heck! Don’t tell a customer their vehicle is junk and not worth anything then turn around and sell it for 2,200 more than I was given! We were planning on getting our son and daughter who are learning to drive a vehicle from there but not anymore! Glad I was able to find a vehicle for the price I could afford but my fault for believing they were just junking my trade in. Sad that the sales person flat out lied to my face saying they don’t deal in shady business but yet can turn around and pull this! Word of mouth can be pretty damaging. I did like the lady in the office she was sweet! But don’t trust this place.

Great car lot. The front desk lady, Zach and Adam were awesome and very helpful. I purchased a 2011 GMC Terrain SLE on 12/27/23 for my daughter's Sweet 16. The Terrain runs great and had a very good price. The workers were accommodating, everyone was friendly and NOT pushy at all.